2004
Jeanette Antolin (All-Around, Bars, Beam#, Floor)
Jamie Dantzscher (Bars, Floor#)
Kristen Maloney (Bars; All-Around, Vault, Beam#)
Kate Richardson (All-Around, Vault, Bars, Beam#)
Yvonne Tousek (Beam; Floor#)

2003
Jeanette Antolin (Vault, Bars)
Jamie Dantzscher (All-Around, Vault, Bars, Beam#, Floor)
Kristin Parker (Vault#)
Kate Richardson (All-Around, Bars, Beam, Floor)
Yvonne Tousek (Bars)
Onnie Willis (All-Around, Vault, Beam#, Floor)

2002
Alyssa Beckerman (Beam)
Jamie Dantzscher (All-Around, Vault, Bars, Beam, Floor)
Doni Thompson (Bars)
Yvonne Tousek (All-Around#, Bars)
Onnie Willis (All-Around, Vault#, Bars, Floor)

2001
Mohini Bhardwaj (All-Around, Bars, Floor)
Jamie Dantzscher (Vault#, Bars, Floor)
Malia Jones (Beam#)
Kristen Maloney (Beam)
Kristin Parker (Vault)
Doni Thompson (Bars, Beam#)
Yvonne Tousek (All-Around, Bars, Beam, Floor#)
Onnie Willis (All-Around, Vault#, Bars, Beam, Floor)

2000
Mohini Bhardwaj (All-Around, Vault, Bars, Beam)
Lena Degteva (All-Around#, Vault#, Bars, Beam, Floor#)
Heidi Moneymaker (All-Around, Vault, Bars, Floor)
Kristin Parker (All-Around#, Bars#)
Onnie Willis (Vault, Bars#, Floor#)

1999
Mohini Bhardwaj (All-Around#, Bars)
Lena Degteva (All-Around, Vault, Bars, Floor#)
Kiralee Hayashi (All-Around#, Vault, Beam, Floor)
Heidi Moneymaker (All-Around, Vault, Bars, Beam, Floor)
Luisa Portocarrero (Vault, Bars#)

1998
Mohini Bhardwaj (Vault, Bars)
Lena Degteva (All-Around#, Vault)
Susie Erickson (Beam#)
Kiralee Hayashi (All-Around, Vault#, Bars, Beam#)
Heidi Moneymaker (All-Around, Vault#, Bars)
Stella Umeh (Vault#, Beam, Floor)

1997
Lena Degteva (All-Around#, Vault)
Kiralee Hayashi (Beam#)
Leah Homma (All-Around, Bars, Beam, Floor#)
Amy Smith (Vault, Floor)
Stella Umeh (Bars)

Lena Degteva earned 13 career All-America honors.

1996
Corinne Chee (Beam)
Leah Homma (Bars#)
Luisa Portocarrero (Beam)
Stella Umeh (Bars, Beam)

1995
Corinne Chee (Beam#)
Leah Homma (Bars)
Kareema Marrow (Bars, Floor)
Amy Smith (Floor)
Stella Umeh (All-Around, Bars, Beam, Floor)

1994
Kareema Marrow (All-Around, Floor)
Karen Nelson (Vault)
Leah Homma (All-Around#, Bars#)

1993
Carol Ulrich (Beam)
Paula Rasmussen (Beam)
Kareema Marrow (All-Around#, Vault)

1992
Rhonda Faehn (All-Around#, Beam#)
Amy Thorne (Floor#)
Karen Nelson (Vault#)

1990
Jill Andrews (All-Around, Vault)
Carol Ulrich (All-Around, Beam)

1989
Jill Andrews (Beam, Vault, All-Around)
Kim Hamilton (Vault, Floor)
Shawn McGinnis (Bars, Floor)
Tanya Service (All-Around, Vault, Bars, Floor)

1988
Jill Andrews (All-Around, Vault)
Renee Kelly (Floor)
Kim Hamilton (All-Around, Bars, Floor)
Amy Lucena (Vault)

Kim Hamilton earned three first-team All-America honors on floor when she won the NCAA Championships in 1987, 1988 and 1999.

1987
Jill Andrews (Vault)
Kim Hamilton (Floor)
Amy Lucena (Vault)
Birgit Schier (Bars)
Tanya Service (Vault, Floor)

1986
Gigi Zosa (All-Around, Beam, Bars)

1984
Donna Kemp (Beam, All-Around)
Karen McMullin (Bars, Beam)
Rhonda Schwandt (Vault)

1983
Donna Kemp (All-Around)

1982
Sharon Shapiro (All-Around, Vault, Beam)
Anne Kitabayashi (Bars)

*NCAA competition only, # - Second-team honors